Tata Motors Falls 7%: Is JLR Pulling the Stock Down?
On Nov 17, investors in TMPV (Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles) had to face a harsh reality check, as shares of the newly listed entity plunged 7% to an intraday low of ₹363 on the NSE. For the quarter ended Sept 30, the headline numbers flashed a staggering consolidated net profit of ₹76,170 cr.
However, at the same time, the market looked past this figure and focused instead on the operational headwinds facing its luxury arm, Jaguar Land Rover (JLR). An exceptional one-time gain drove the ₹82,616 cr revenue almost entirely. This gain had resulted from the accounting adjustments of the recent commercial vehicles demerger. Without this paper gain, the company actually posted an adjusted loss. This combined with a severe guidance cut for JLR, sent bears on a rampage.
This is the first quarterly result reported by the passenger vehicles business as a standalone listed entity following the historic corporate split. Despite the separation, the fortunes of the passenger vehicle stock remain heavily tied to the performance of JLR. Currently, JLR contributes to more than two-thirds of the overall business revenue. So, the stock has taken a beating despite a headline profit boom, placing an important question for investors. Is this a knee-jerk reaction to a one-off event, or a warning sign of deeper structural cracks in the JLR growth story?
JLR's Cyber Nightmare: How Bad is the Damage?
JLR is the crown jewel of Tata Motors' PV portfolio. The main trigger for the sell-off was a crisis in the UK (United Kingdom). JLR endured a debilitating cyberattack in early Sept 2025 that effectively froze its operations. This incident had suspended production at the British carmaker’s facilities for over a month. Further, this caused a ripple effect that decimated its quarterly financials.
JLR’s revenue for the quarter fell 24.3% YoY to £4.9 bn. The production halt meant the company could not wholesale vehicles. This led to a sharp contraction in cash flow. Consequently, JLR management was forced to slash its full-year guidance. This was the move that soured investor sentiment. The company has lowered its EBIT margin outlook for FY26 to a range of 0% to 2%. This was a steep drop from the earlier forecast of 5% to 7%.
Furthermore, the company reversed its earlier forecast of breaking even on cash flow. Now, it is projecting a negative free cash flow of £2.2 bn to £2.5 bn. With guidance cut and margins under pressure, the big ask for the market is: can JLR bounce back quickly enough to save the fiscal year, or is the damage to its premium brand and order book more permanent than admitted?
What Do the Numbers Really Say?
The consolidated profit figure can be a classic case of an accounting mirage. If the one-time gain is taken away, the financial health of the company would look very different.
As the volume dropped (as they did by 24.2% excluding the China JV), the operating leverage worked in reverse. This erased the margins rapidly. The market's negative reaction is an indicator that investors are prioritising these core operational metrics over the statutory profit figure.
Furthermore, they are pricing in the risk that the recovery at JLR might take longer than expected. This is especially evident from the given lowered guidance and the ongoing macroeconomic challenges in major markets like China and Europe.
Domestic Resilience
Amidst the gloom surrounding JLR, the domestic India business provided a silver lining, showcasing resilience and growth. On a standalone basis, Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles (the India operations) revenue has climbed 15.6%. The company has successfully cemented its position as the number two player in the Indian passenger vehicle market.
There is also a successful diversification away from pure petrol and diesel models. Product-wise, the Nexon SUV retained its title as the industry’s top-selling model in Sept and Oct. The Punch micro-SUV also saw robust demand, reaching >40,000 units in the same period. Even the flagship Harrier and Safari models recorded their highest-ever volumes, driven by the launch of new variants and the Harrier.ev.
For the stock to recover, investors will need to see clear evidence in the coming quarters that JLR has truly put the cyber incident behind it and can navigate the demand slump in China. Until then, the India growth story may struggle to lift the overall sentiment.
Source
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. It is not produced by the desk of the Kotak Securities Research Team, nor is it a report published by the Kotak Securities Research Team. The information presented is compiled from several secondary sources available on the internet and may change over time. Investors should conduct their own research and consult with financial professionals before making any investment decisions. Read the full disclaimer here.
Investments in securities market are subject to market risks, read all the related documents carefully before investing. Brokerage will not exceed SEBI prescribed limit. The securities are quoted as an example and not as a recommendation. SEBI Registration No-INZ000200137 Member Id NSE-08081; BSE-673; MSE-1024, MCX-56285, NCDEX-1262.