Budgetary Over-reach

Over-budgeting hurts the larger economy more than the govt, as New Delhi is allowed to get away with behaving arbitrarily and then hiding the reality behind bogus numbers, writes T N Ninan

T N Ninan, Business Standard
25th January

The problem with the Budget in recent years is not that they didn’t do enough. Rather, finance ministers tried to do too much. This is not just with regard to tax revenue, on which the assumptions went particularly wrong last year (2018-19) and may do so again this year, but also with expenditure. For instance, this year’s central expenditure on “schemes” and projects is slated to be fully 48 per cent more than two years ago. Even if the money were available, would government departments be able to spend on that scale?

When it comes to gross tax revenue, though the numbers have fallen short of what was announced, the fact is that the ratio of such revenue to gross domestic product (GDP) has been growing through the six years of the two Narendra Modi governments — from 10.14 per cent in 2013-14 to an expected 11.72 per cent this year. Even if revenue this year were to fall short by, say, Rs 2 trillion (or about 8 per cent), as some commentators expect, the figure in relation to GDP (itself smaller than expected) would still be notably better than in 2013-14 — despite disappointment with goods and services tax (GST) collections.

In other words, while there is an issue with GST, the real problem is that budgeting has been too ambitious. Note that a good bit of the surge in revenue has come from non-tax sources — transfers from government companies in the form of extra dividends, offloading government shareholding (including to cash-rich government enterprises because there was no time to sell to others), revenue from licence fees and spectrum use, and the like. And so this year’s non-tax revenue is slated to be 63 per cent more than what was achieved two years ago. It won’t happen, of course.

The price for over-budgeting is paid by the sectors that have been bled white, like telecom and government companies. It is also paid by organisations to which the government owes money but which don’t get paid (think Hindustan Aeronautics), by organisations like the Food Corporation that are forced to borrow from wherever they can because the government is not paying them on time, and by states which don’t get their share of central taxes when they are due. There is a price for trying to do too much, and the larger economy pays it more than the central government because New Delhi is allowed to get away with behaving arbitrarily and then hiding the reality behind the bogus numbers that it presents to the country.

Over-budgeting happens in particular during periods of economic slowdown — which the government either does not anticipate or is unable to foresee. It is hard, for instance, to understand how the government assumed 7 per cent real GDP growth (and about 12 per cent nominal growth) this year, when it was already clear in July that the system was on the skids. It is no defence to say that others (like the International Monetary Fund) also did not anticipate the extent of the slowdown; everyone knows that the IMF habitually gets its numbers wrong in its World Economic Outlook. The result was that the government sector grew in the last quarter by 15 per cent, while the rest of the economy was growing at barely 3 per cent.

The debate about whether the government should stick to a modicum of fiscal discipline in its Budget for 2020-21, or forget the deficit and open the tap, should be seen against this backdrop. It should also be viewed from the perspective of the level of debt in relation to GDP (too high and climbing higher), and what a higher level of borrowing might do to interest rates that are high too. While it could be argued that a counter-cyclical fiscal policy points to opening the tap, the reality is that the fiscal sins of the past are already extracting their price in different ways. There is a time for atonement, and for lowering one’s expectations of the economy — and therefore not trying to do too much in the Budget.

Disclaimer: This information is from a third party—Business Standard—offered through a tie-up to Kotak Securities customers for free for life. The third party content is not created or endorsed by any business offering products or services through it. The provision of this third party content is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute a research call, recommendation or solicitation to purchase or sell any security or make any other type of investment or investment decision. Also, the views and opinions stated in the content belong to Business Standard. Kotak Securities does not uphold nor promote any of the views. These reports do not, in any way, qualify as a Kotak Securities research report.

A few links for further reading

Fix the holes in your investments and insurance plans ahead of the new year

Make changes where required so that your investment and insurance portfolio are equipped to meet the rigours that 2020 may have to offer. With the year drawing to a close, your thoughts may have turned to taking a holiday and visiting a new destination. Or you may want to just curl up in a blanket and laze around by a bonfire. While you do deserve some rest after toiling for the entire year, one essential task you must not overlook is to check your financial portfolio and ensure it is in good shape.

Why Modi govt's UDAN scheme is struggling?

‘Fly to Cooch Behar or Kolhapur’: The government promised the common person this with UDAN, its regional air-connectivity scheme. The prime minister inaugurated the first UDAN flight in April 2017, starting a programme that aimed to fly on 688 routes. Only 232 routes — a third of that planned —are working to date. At least two airlines that won UDAN contracts have folded up; scores of airports and airstrips cannot accommodate flights, and policy changes make business difficult. Undeterred, the government now wants to use sea planes to connect cities. That would fly, if the rest of the UDAN scheme is put in order.

Are Indian banks out of the woods?

Earnings season is over at most Indian banks. Looking at the September-quarter results, one might be tempted to say the worst is behind for the India banking industry.

Want to get this in your email?